An Accident of Stars is one of the most ambitious political commentaries that I have read, set in a distinctive portal fantasy. The book revolves around Saffron Coulter, an Australian teenager who stumbles into a new world where magic is real and technology is rudimentary. Guided by another ‘worldwalker’, Gwen, she becomes ensnared in the latest coup.
The worldbuilding is exquisite, the religious factions and different nations well fleshed. The politics are complex but well explained. The characters are distinct, believable and well rounded. The younger generation are more perceptive and accepting than their elders – but isn’t that so often the case on Earth too? The plot moves at a steady pace and information is expertly drip fed as it progresses. Meadows is clearly a talented author from page one.
The good guys aren’t wholly good. They have their vices, biases, betrayals and weaknesses, as they should. The bad guys are less complete. Their motivations seem unclear and I would like to see them develop more in future.
If I had to choose one way the novel could be improved, I would advise adding a vehicle for comic relief. It’s an emotionally heavy book and would benefit from a little whimsy occasionally. There are lighter moments – chats between old friends, a little spark of romance – but for me, when things are at their darkest is when a little black humour is most needed.
Truthfully, I find it remarkable that there isn’t more hype surrounding this series. To speculate, I’d attribute this to the left leaning political influences which are becoming less popular. Polyamory, varied sexualities, transgender characters, no concept of promiscuity – this book is composed with radical liberal ideology and perhaps that is a step too far for the average reader. Personally, I find it a delight that there isn’t a straight, cisgender, white man to be found and eagerly anticipate the rest of the series.
Overall, An Accident of Stars is a masterpiece and I look forward to reading more about Saffron’s adventures.
Written By: ivetafox
Favourite Game – Long Live the Queen || Favourite Film – Sweeney Todd || Favourite Book – Wuthering Heights
About: Ivy is a disabled, autistic writer from the UK, passionate about inclusive gaming. When not reviewing, she can be found writing short stories and micro fiction or reading the latest gothic novel.
Donate: https://ko-fi.com/storiesbyivy
