Pending Plays > Comics & Graphic Novels > Lily of the Valley – Manhwa Review

Lily of the Valley – Manhwa Review

The book cover of "Lily of the valley" by Rangrari. The book cover of "Lily of the valley" by Rangrari.
Share this:

A korean webcomic (릴리 오브 더 밸리) written and drawn by Rangrari, who is most known by her “Bad thinking diary” series. You can read it for free on the distributor, Ridibooks.


Art: 5/5 stars

Full color, fully rendered with a 3d effect and hyper-realistic backgrounds. Did the artist sell their soul?

Story: 4.5/5

I didn’t expect the ending, mostly because of clichés. Very happy about the surprise.
Polyamory ftw.

Characters: 4/5

I really liked Anna, especially the way she contributed positively to the surprising ending. Saw myself in her. 
I wish her well.

Themes: 5/5

The execution of the question “what is love? Is it romance or pleasure? Or both?” is really really well done here. Especially how there’s no clear answer and left for the reader to decide, as well as highlighting how different it is for everyone, including all three main characters. 

CriteriaScoresOur Score
Art1-55
Pacing1-54
Characters1-54
Writing Style1-54.5
Originality1-54

I could rate it 5 stars, but I didn’t like that one hetero sex scene, so minus 0.25 stars it is. Luckily it was very short. :’)

Overall very recommended. It has GL smut, gorgeous art, deep characters especially for that length, ace rep, psychological exploration, good writing, breaking from clichés, polyamory, harem, and is so short you can read it in one go. Deserves to be sold in bookstores.


Finished reading: 14th October 2025
~Arden Skye

Check my other content on: Newsletter | Youtube | My books


Pending Plays is an ever growing collective of people volunteering their spare time to bring you their thoughts and opinions on all things entertainment. This site could not function without their good will and easgerness to see us success. It is also these volunteers who put the funds towards keeping this website running. If you have enjoyed the content you've seen today and want to help support these volunteers and keep this website running, please consider donating. You can do this by clicking "Support Us" on the Menu, or by clicking the "Support Us" widget in the bottom left. Every donation helps us massively and goes a long way.
Stay up to date with new content, by subscribing to our newsletter.

Leave a Reply